nix is a package manager that does things a little differently. I have fascinated by nix ever since Christine Koppelt told me about it a few years back when we were working together in Munich.

The basic idea behind nix, is that all sofware is kept in a content addressable* store, and only the exact dependencies needed are made available in a build, dev or runtime environment. The design has some similarity with git and aims to solve similar problems as docker. From an abstract perspective, nix presents the cleanest approach to building software that is currently available.

Here are a few of the selling points, that I hope to realize with nix:

1. 100% conflict free dependency management
2. (Almost) reproducible builds
3. Declaratively defined “cheap” run-time environments for applications, development and whole systems.
4. Create minimal VM or Docker images containing those environments

Unfortunately, nix still has a rather steep learning curve. I have been banging my head against the table quite a few times over the past week, and this is AFTER I printed the manual and read most of it :) In this note, I’ll take you along for the journey of a first more serios experiment: building the latest emacs, with a few extras enabled.

In the following sections we will actually create four different build variant that realize our goal following slightly different approaches:

1. Emacs From Scratch
2. Refactoring nixpkgs' Emacs
3. Overriding nixpkgs' emacs
4. The emacs overlay

If you are only interested in using the results, you can direcly skip to the GitHub repository.

WARNING: This post assumes some basic familiarity with nix, to follow the examples in detail. Nevertheless, I hope that this post will allow you to get some idea about what is possible, and how things are done in the nix world.

*) The nix storage address is the hash of the reciept (“derivation”) that was used to build the artifact, and not the hash of the artifact itself. This is mainly since nix has to deal with builds that are non-reproducible. We may see a content addressable nix variant in the near future.

Available emacs versions

The usual way to install emacs with nix is to use the command:

; nix-env -iA nixpkgs.emacs

At the time of this writing, this will install emacs-27.2. This is the latest released version, but 4 months old by now and 5000+ commits behind master. We want to run something a little bit more recent, ideally with native compilation (--with-native-compilation) and native JSON support (--with-json) enabled.

Variant 1 – Emacs From scratch

The first emacs package we are going to build is starting from scratch. I am using a .nix template that is derived from this nix pill:

; cat emacs-from-scratch.nix
with {
  pkgs = import <nixpkgs> {}; # make nixpkgs available 
};

pkgs.stdenv.mkDerivation {
  name = "emacs-head";
  # ... here goes the receipt ...
}

This file already compiles, and gives us a (pretty useless) derivation, which we can view with:

nix show-derivation $( nix-instantiate -f emacs-from-scratch.nix )

Step 1.1 – Pull emacs sources from GitHub

To pull the sources from GitHub, we add the following statement to our .nix file:

  src = pkgs.fetchFromGitHub {
      owner = "emacs-mirror";
      repo = "emacs";
      rev = "4d439744685b6b2492685124994120ebd1fa4abb"; # git-SHA of curret master HEAD
      sha256 = "00vxb83571r39r0dbzkr9agjfmqs929lhq9rwf8akvqghc412apf";
  };

The sha256 content is a nix-specific hash of the downloaded tar file. The easiest way to get it is to build the derivation without sha256 specified, and extract the expected sha from the error message.

We build the package with

; nix-build emacs-from-scratch.nix
...
configuring
no configure script, doing nothing
building
build flags: SHELL=/nix/store/x0dcb2rxlzf32g0ddfkqqz1sfcyx4yay-bash-4.4-p23/bin/bash
There seems to be no "configure" file in this directory.
Running ./autogen.sh ...
./autogen.sh
...
Your system seems to be missing the following tool(s):
autoconf (missing)

and get an build-time (!) error that autoconf is missing.

To resolve the situation we make the following changes:

1. Add preConfigure = "./autogen.sh", to generate a suitable configure file. (The necessity of this step took me WAY TOO LONG to figure out 😅).

2. Add buildInputs = [ pkgs.autoconf ] to make autoconf available in the build environment.

While at it we also add configureFlags = ["--without-all"] as to simplify our lives for the time being.

Hint: Use nix-shell --pure emacs-from-scratch.nix to drop into an interactive build environment. The build phases can be manually executed with commands like unpackPhase. I used this to run ./configure --help to get information about the available configure flags.

Step 1.2 - A first try …

After resolving a first set of dependecny errors, we arrive a the following file:

with rec {
  pkgs = import <nixpkgs> {};
};

pkgs.stdenv.mkDerivation {
   name = "emacs-head";
   src = pkgs.fetchFromGitHub {
       owner = "emacs-mirror";
       repo = "emacs";
       rev = "4d439744685b6b2492685124994120ebd1fa4abb";
       sha256 = "00vxb83571r39r0dbzkr9agjfmqs929lhq9rwf8akvqghc412apf";
  };
  preConfigure = "./autogen.sh";
  configureFlags = ["--without-all"];
  buildInputs = [ pkgs.autoconf pkgs.texinfo pkgs.ncurses ];
}

The build proceeds through the configure phase, and fails after a few minutes with the following error:

/nix/store/x0dcb2rxlzf32g0ddfkqqz1sfcyx4yay-bash-4.4-p23/bin/bash: /bin/pwd: No such file or directory

pwd(1) is part of the GNU coreutils, which is available in the nix build environment by default. It’s however, not at its standard location /bin/pwd but in the nix store, in my case at: /nix/store/937f5738d2frws07ixcpg5ip176pfss1-coreutils-8.32/bin/pwd

Step 1.3 – Patching the Makefiles

We have to patch the Makefiles in order to fix the issue. Taking some inspiration from the nikpgs emacs derivation, we add the following patches to our .nix file:

postPatch = pkgs.lib.concatStringsSep "\n" [
  ''
  for makefile_in in $(find . -name Makefile.in -print); do
    substituteInPlace $makefile_in --replace /bin/pwd pwd
  done
  substituteInPlace src/Makefile.in --replace 'RUN_TEMACS = ./temacs' 'RUN_TEMACS = env -i ./temacs'
  substituteInPlace lisp/international/mule-cmds.el --replace /usr/share/locale ${pkgs.gettext}/share/locale
  ''
];

With these patches the build succeeds and we have our first emacs.

; nix-build emacs-from-scrach.nix
...
/nix/store/qh9v8rnp8bjm18r7wz9cq7khhqf63wvw-emacs-head

; /nix/store/qh9v8rnp8bjm18r7wz9cq7khhqf63wvw-emacs-head/bin/emacs --version
GNU Emacs 28.0.50
...

Step 1.4 – Adding configure flags

We are now removing the --without-all configure flag, to arrive at a more featureful emacs variant. Looking at the build errors, we need to add pkgs.gnutls and pkgs.pkg-config to the buildInputs, and get a working version.

• For --with-json we need pkgs.janson as well.
• For --with-native-compilation we add pkgs.libgccjit and pkgs.zlib, and set the environment variables:

  NATIVE_FULL_AOT = "1";
  LIBRARY_PATH = "${pkgs.stdenv.cc.libc}/lib";
  

In all those cases, adding the entry to buildInputs was sufficient for the build process to pick up the dependency. This means that LD_FLAGS and CFLAGS have been set accordingly without any need for additional configuration.

The final emacs-from-scratch.nix file looks as follows:

with rec {
  pkgs = import <nixpkgs> {};
};

pkgs.stdenv.mkDerivation {
  name = "emacs-head";
  src = pkgs.fetchFromGitHub {
      owner = "emacs-mirror";
      repo = "emacs";
      rev = "4d439744685b6b2492685124994120ebd1fa4abb";
      sha256 = "00vxb83571r39r0dbzkr9agjfmqs929lhq9rwf8akvqghc412apf";
  };
  # Environtment for --native-compilation
  NATIVE_FULL_AOT = "1";
  LIBRARY_PATH = "${pkgs.stdenv.cc.libc}/lib";

  # Dependencies
  buildInputs = [
    pkgs.autoconf pkgs.texinfo pkgs.ncurses # --without-all
    pkgs.gnutls pkgs.pkg-config # normal build
    pkgs.jansson # --with-json
    pkgs.zlib pkgs.libgccjit # --with-native-compilation
  ];

  postPatch = pkgs.lib.concatStringsSep "\n" [
    ''
    for makefile_in in $(find . -name Makefile.in -print); do
      substituteInPlace $makefile_in --replace /bin/pwd pwd
    done
    substituteInPlace src/Makefile.in --replace 'RUN_TEMACS = ./temacs' 'RUN_TEMACS = env -i ./temacs'
    substituteInPlace lisp/international/mule-cmds.el --replace /usr/share/locale ${pkgs.gettext}/share/locale
    ''
  ];
  preConfigure = "./autogen.sh";
  configureFlags = [ "--with-json" "--with-native-compilation" ];
}

To be fair, I don’t expect --with-native-compilation to fully work at this point, since there are a few suspicious lisp patches in the upstream repository that we did not apply yet.

However, emacs compiles and starts-up fine:

$( nix-build emacs-from-scratch.nix )/bin/emacs 

Variant 2 - Refactoring nixpkgs' Emacs

To get a fully functional emacs version we want to leverage the community know-how, and avoid discovering all the pit-falls the hard way.

The upstream emacs derivation available in nixpkgs is available here here. The following 3 files are relevant for the emacs build:

• 27.nix calls generic.nix and specifies some patches
• generic.nix specifies the source tar-ball, dependency and configure options
• all-packages.nix calls generic.nix with some overrides and registers the derivation in the <nixpkgs> name-space

This setup is quite complex, and involves a lot of indirection that is not needed for our purposes. In the next steps, we will refactor these three files, and produce a single-file version that is functionally identical to the above for the cases of graphical OSX builds and non-graphical Linux builds.

Step 2.1 - Consolidate nix source files

We will refrain from explaining the refactoring steps full detail. The interested reader can alwas refer to the commit log. On a high level, we proceeded as follows:

1. Remove the all-package.nix dependency by providing an independent entry point emacs-refactored.nix of the form:

   with import <nipkgs> {}; callPackage ./27.nix { ... }
   

2. Merge 27.nix and generic.nix into emacs-refactored.nix by substituting file contents for the import calls.
3. Cleanup by inlining calls and specializing to the OSX/Linux configuration described above.

After each step we check the file defines an identical build by using nix-instantiate -f <filename>. If the retured hash value is identical, we have not changed the build.

Step 2.2 - Pull latest sources

Next we change src to pull from the latest GitHub master, as we did above. We fix the build by:

• Remove the patches as they no-longer seem to apply
• Add autoconf and texinfo dependencies to buildInputs
• Run ./autogen.sh from the pre-configure hook

Step 2.3 Enable Native Compilation and native JSON

The upstream emacs package thankfully has already built-in nativeComp parameter! I am pretty sure we should be able to set this with a command-line switch (--args), but I could not get this to work. (What seems to work is to use the following nix expression: nix-build -E 'with import <nixpkgs> {}; emacs.override { nativeComp = true; }') We set this parameter to true to enable nativeComp.

Native JSON support is activated by adding “–with-json” as configure flag. The jansson dependency is already speficified.

With this changes, nix-build goes right through an we should have a fully functional emacs --with-json and --with--native-compilation running! To be sure, we check this by printing the lisp variable system-configuration-options which contains a copy of the build flags:

; $( nix-build emacs-refactored.nix )/bin/emacs -nw -q --batch --eval '(message system-configuration-options)'
--prefix=/nix/store/ ... --with-native-compilation --with-json

The complete build definition can be found here.

Variant 3 – Overriding nixpkgs' emacs

In going through the above steps, one notes, that there were actually very few modifications to the stock emacs package necessary to build the latest emacs@head version: We changed src, added a preConfigure entry, and specified two more dependencies.

It is possible to apply those changes to upstream derivation, using the package overrides mechanism. The resulting file looks like this:

; cat emacs-override.nix
with (import <nixpkgs> {});

(emacs-nox.override {
     nativeComp = true;
}).overrideAttrs (old : {
     pname = "emacs";
     version = "head";
     src = fetchFromGitHub {
        owner = "emacs-mirror";
        repo = "emacs";
        rev = "4d439744685b6b2492685124994120ebd1fa4abb";
        sha256 = "00vxb83571r39r0dbzkr9agjfmqs929lhq9rwf8akvqghc412apf";
     };
     patches = [];
     configureFlags = old.configureFlags ++ ["--with-json"];
     preConfigure = "./autogen.sh";
     buildInputs = old.buildInputs ++ [ autoconf texinfo ];
})

Most of the changes shoudl be self-explanatory. Note, that we use .override to override the nativeComp arguments to callPackage, and .overrideAttrs to manipulate the internal of the derivation.

This is the emacs version that I am currently using on my Linux machine. It allows me to leverage the upstream maintenance efforts and only maintain a minimal set of changes that is necessary to build the latest master, with my desired configuration.

Variant 4 – The emacs overlay

An even more powerful mechanism to “override” nixpkg’s packages is the Overlay mechanism.

There is a community maintained emacs-overlay repository available, which seems like it does the job of building the latest emacs with the desired configuration. Initially I discatded this overlay since it looked quite involved (requireing use of NixOs or Home Manager), and does a fair bit more than we need for our set-goal. After having worked through the above versions, I think I understand now how to navigate this complexity, and produce a stand-alone nix-file (GH) that leverages this overlay:

; cat nix-overlay.nix
with rec {
  emacs-overlay = import (builtins.fetchTarball { url = https://github.com/nix-community/emacs-overlay/archive/master.tar.gz; });
  pkgs = import <nixpkgs> { overlays = [ emacs-overlay ]; };
};

pkgs.emacsGcc

The following command will now build the community maintained emacsGcc:

nix-build nix-overlay.nix

To install this emacs version, you could use:

nix-env -f nix-overlay.nix -i ".*"

Note that this version does not include the “–with-json” configuration, we have used before. In order to add this, we would need to specify overrides as we did above.

Conclusion

We have seen four different methods to install the latest-gratest emacs with a custom configuration. This exercise has been a good learning experience for me. I hope that this writeup is somewhat helpful for you as well in your journey to find yourself around with nix.

While working on this project, I have asked the nix community multiple times for support over the following channels:

• Chat/Matrix
• StackOverflow
• Forum/Discourse

In all cases, I got very helpful replies within a few minutes. This has been an outstanding experience!

What I took away from this exercise is that nix is a very powerful tool, that has the potential to change how we build sofware and manage runtime environments. A lot of heavy lifting has been taken place behind the scenes to make this possible. At this point in time, the user-facing APIs are still very complicated, and sometimes feel rough. To get productive you have to dig into the nix expression language, which is not all that complicated, but requires a certain time investment.

If you are a beginner and want to dig deeper, I would recommend to:

1. Watch some of the intro videos from Burke Libbey’s YouTube Channel
2. Work through the first few Nix pills
3. Spent some quality time with the Nix manual and the NixPkgs manual.

Also don’t hesitate to get in touch with community via chat!